CITIZENS   FOR  LIMITED  TAXATION  &  GOVERNMENT
and the
Citizens Economic Research Foundation

 

CLT UPDATE
Friday, November 1, 2002

Conduct unbecoming Shannon O'Brien


The only place most of us hear the word "unbecoming" is in the military, re: the phrase "conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman."

We would add ... "and a candidate for Governor."

CLT NEWS RELEASE
Oct. 31, 2002
Conduct Unbecoming Shannon O'Brien


Who knew one little word could cause such a flap? ...

Sure, "unbecoming" can be used to describe a really bad haircut. It is also commonly used in the phrase "conduct unbecoming an officer." But then again the state treasurer - who described her role with a foundering health care firm as being that of "a sailor rather than an admiral" - might not be familiar with that turn of phrase.

A Boston Herald editorial
Nov. 1, 2002
Playing word games


Republican Mitt Romney launched a blistering new attack on gubernatorial rival Shannon P. O'Brien yesterday, warning that her "Gang of Three" insider cronies will usher in a tax-and-spend renaissance.

Picking up his rhetoric markedly four days from the election, Romney said handing Democrats the governor's office, the House and Senate would be an unmitigated disaster.

"Massachusetts is just one step away from total control by the Beacon Hill machine," Romney boomed, standing before massive blowup photos of O'Brien and allies House Speaker Thomas M. Finneran and likely new Senate President Robert E. Travaglini.

The Boston Herald
Nov. 1, 2002
Mitt raps Dem 'gang'


Chip Ford's CLT Commentary

Yesterday, the Boston Herald endorsed Mitt Romney for governor. Later in the day, Romney labeled the potential Beacon Hill "terrible troika" of Finneran, Travglini and O'Brien "the Gang of Three." He didn't compare them to the fictitious and familiar TV mob of "Tony Soprano" so he's apparently safe at the Herald.

Let's hope his innocent and evocative characterization is not exploited as demeaning by the Asian community, or by some misinformed reporter-pundit promoting indignation; that Asians are not as thin-skinned as some writer at a Herald believes others are or can be made to be. Let's hope so, even if the allusion is to real-life ethnic historical figures instead of a mere TV actor's role.


The Gang of Four was a group of four hard-core communists who dreamed of a China with the most orthodox form of communism on Earth. In the mid-1960s they pushed for total destruction of traditional Chinese culture to be replaced by textbook communist ideology and culture.

Their powerful positions enabled them to win support. They became the leading forces in Mao's Cultural Revolution. After Mao's death in 1976, the Gang of Four and the Cultural Revolution was rejected by the Communist Party.

The Gang of Four


The domestic turmoil in China that began in 1966 and continued until Chairman Mao Zedong's death in 1976 is known as the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution....

The Chinese government itself admits that over 35,000 people were killed in incidents of mob violence from 1966 to 1968, but some Western analysts have placed the number at more than 400,000....

Mao himself died in September 1976, and Hua and the 'moderate' elements in the Party arrested Jiang Qing and the radical leaders associated with her (called the 'Gang of Four') within a month.

The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution
by Brian R. Train


So will the Boston Herald's "Bone-headed bigot of the week award" be presented to its endorsed candidate for governor this week? Let's watch "The Buzz" column in Sunday's Herald for PC consistency!

It's satisfying to watch a blind pundit plunge into the fetid PC swamp only to be discovered by a grinning alligator!

On the other hand, that Boston Herald report today also provides us with a great Shannon O'Brien quote-to-keep for the files: "O'Brien ... said she - unlike Romney and past GOP governors - can work with her allies in the Legislature... 'I know how to get things done on Beacon Hill. I know how to break through the gridlock in the Legislature,' O'Brien said."

Translation: "Gridlock, what gridlock? Believe me, gridlock will be obsolete if I'm elected -- bring in the tax-and-spend steamroller!"

Chip Ford


CLT NEWS RELEASE
Thursday, October 31, 2002

Contact:  Barbara Anderson (508) 384-0100 
               Chip Ford (781) 631-6842

Conduct Unbecoming Shannon O'Brien

The only place most of us hear the word "unbecoming" is in the military, re: the phrase "conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman."

We would add ... "and a candidate for Governor."

-30-

Return to top


The Boston Herald
Friday, November 1, 2002

A Boston Herald editorial
Playing word games

Who knew one little word could cause such a flap?

Well, as this often excruciating political season winds to a close, why should we be surprised? Gubernatorial candidates Shannon O'Brien and Mitt Romney have both run campaign ads relative to each other's business dealings that only an accountant could love - and even an accountant would be hard-pressed to explain.

Whatever...

Now the campaign has turned to word games. In the course of Tuesday's night's debate, Romney, tired of listening to O'Brien lying about his position on abortion rights, called her comments "unbecoming." He used the word one other time during the debate, then switched to "inappropriate." Most folks would use the two words interchangeably.

Ah, but this is Massachusetts within days of an election and what the Democratic candidate needs is one more triviality to rev up the troops.

Sure, "unbecoming" can be used to describe a really bad haircut. It is also commonly used in the phrase "conduct unbecoming an officer." But then again the state treasurer - who described her role with a foundering health care firm as being that of "a sailor rather than an admiral" - might not be familiar with that turn of phrase.

Return to top


The Boston Herald
Friday, November 1, 2002

Mitt raps Dem 'gang'
by David R. Guarino and Elisabeth J. Beardsley

Republican Mitt Romney launched a blistering new attack on gubernatorial rival Shannon P. O'Brien yesterday, warning that her "Gang of Three" insider cronies will usher in a tax-and-spend renaissance.

Picking up his rhetoric markedly four days from the election, Romney said handing Democrats the governor's office, the House and Senate would be an unmitigated disaster.

"Massachusetts is just one step away from total control by the Beacon Hill machine," Romney boomed, standing before massive blowup photos of O'Brien and allies House Speaker Thomas M. Finneran and likely new Senate President Robert E. Travaglini.

"This is a group of people who want to take Massachusetts back to the days of single-party monopoly, where a few people can sit in a room and make any decision they want to," he said at a Boston press conference.

Romney's campaign also leveled a new volley at O'Brien's family, saying her father, Edward, a longtime member of the Governor's Council, creates a possible "conflict of interest" for the Democratic nominee.

O'Brien, trying to turn the tables, said Romney's attacks have the markings of a losing candidate grasping for straws. She said Romney's GOP is just as much to blame for all that ails Beacon Hill.

"Remember, we've had 12 years of Republican governors who promised us that they were going to end the patronage, who promised us that they were going to shrink the size of state government - they broke those promises," O'Brien said.

For Romney, the all-Democrat warnings will become a hallmark of what aides say will be an aggressive, late-campaign push to taint O'Brien - who held a narrow lead in Tuesday's Boston Herald poll.

Romney, like past GOP candidates, should be able to make hay by reminding voters of 1980s tax hikes when Democrats controlled all three branches of government, the aides said. Romney's camp believes late-deciding, mostly independent voters can easily be wooed by the concept that there should be checks and balances to Democrat rule.

With the expected election of East Boston's Travaglini as president of the Senate, O'Brien would have close ties to both legislative leaders. Travaglini's brother, Michael, is O'Brien's top deputy and, in the House, Finneran is a close friend and supporter.

Since tradition gives the three powerful leaders control of most budgeting and legislative decisions, Romney said O'Brien's election would literally create a three-headed monster.

"They will do everything and anything they want if that gang of three were allowed to be created," Romney said. "What that means is they would be able to raise taxes with impunity ... they'd be able to extend patronage, more spending, more debt."

Romney pointed to the last Democrat-controlled government - under former Gov. Michael S. Dukakis.

"We can't afford to go back to the ugly days of Taxachusetts," Romney said. While drawing the legislative leaders fully into the campaign, Romney was careful to draw only political differences with Finneran.

"I think we'll disagree on a lot of issues and I expect to really go to battle with Tom Finneran," Romney said. "But I think he's a very capable, well-meaning person. I expect to work with him in much the same what that I'm told (former Gov.) Bill Weld used to work with the leadership of the Legislature."

The tactic by Romney is a familiar one for Republicans, who have consistently won the office by appealing to independent-minded voters and blasting Democrats as tax-and-spend liberals.

O'Brien, touring a Roxbury bakery with Mayor Thomas M. Menino and Attorney General Tom Reilly, said she - unlike Romney and past GOP governors - can work with her allies in the Legislature.

"I know how to get things done on Beacon Hill. I know how to break through the gridlock in the Legislature," O'Brien said.

O'Brien noted that Finneran critics in the Legislature have joined her campaign, several hosting a "Women for O'Brien" rally outside the State House yesterday.

"I've taken a position that I'm going to constantly stand up for the taxpayers of this state, I'm going to fight for working families, and I'm going to do it in a way that regardless of party affiliation, will get the job done," she said.

Finneran declined comment and Travaglini didn't return phone calls.

But Romney's campaign, when asked, also added her father into the mix of insiders. Campaign spokesman Eric Fehrnstrom said the senior O'Brien creates a possible ethical problem if the Democrat wins the Corner Office.

"Eddie O'Brien is a longtime member of the governor's council and the governor makes judicial appointments - that appears to pose a conflict," he said.

O'Brien's campaign said Romney's attacks look "desperate" and said her father shouldn't be an issue. "Anyone who knows Ed O'Brien knows he doesn't roll over for anyone," said O'Brien spokesman Adrian Durbin.

Both campaigns also released new television ads yesterday, O'Brien wading back into negativity over Romney's business record. The ad claims Romney was still CEO of Bain Capital while running the Olympics and "made a fortune" off the $102 million sale of an Indiana paper company.

"Now ask yourself, can you trust Mitt Romney?" it ends.

Romney's campaign said the ad shows "desperation" and that O'Brien "will go to any length to take the attention off her poor debate performance."

The Republican released his own new ad, a commercial where Romney says O'Brien will raise taxes. "We don't need more taxes, we need more jobs, it's time for change," he said.

Return to top


NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml


Return to CLT Updates page

Return to CLT home page