CITIZENS   FOR  LIMITED  TAXATION  &  GOVERNMENT
and the
Citizens Economic Research Foundation

 

CLT UPDATE
Saturday, June 1, 2002

De Tocqueville warned us


And the oddity among those on Beacon Hill is the amount of mail lawmakers are continuing to receive, not in opposition to tax increases, but asking for more of them....

A conclusion gaining support is that the number on the public payroll has swelled so much over the years that nearly every family in the commonwealth has a member or a relative, or knows someone down the street, who is employed in the public sector and who would suffer from program cuts or the elimination of jobs.

Those who aren't affected in some way by such cutbacks are fast becoming the minority taxpayers, and this offers a whole new game for lawmakers.

A Taunton Gazette editorial
Jun. 1, 2002
In a twist, residents calling for more taxes


Let us now suppose that the legislative authority is vested in the lowest order: there are two striking reasons which show that the tendency of the expenditures will be to increase, not to diminish.

As the great majority of those who create the laws have no taxable property, all the money that is spent for the community appears to be spent to their advantage, at no cost of their own, and those who have some little property readily find means of so regulating the taxes that they weigh upon the wealthy and profit the poor, although the rich cannot take the same advantage when they are in possession of the government.

In countries in which the poor have the exclusive power of making the laws, no great economy of public expenditure ought to be expected; that expenditure will always be considerable either because the taxes cannot weigh upon those who levy them or because they are levied in such a manner as not to reach these poorer classes. In other words, the government of the democracy is the only one under which the power that votes the taxes escapes the payment of them....

... I have already observed that the advantage of democracy is not, as has sometimes been observed, that it protects the interests of all, but simply that it protects those of the majority....

Alexis de Tocqueville
Democracy in America (1835)
Chapter 13: Government of the Democracy in America


Chip Ford's CLT Commentary

Again, what more can I add? Perhaps the Gimme Lobby has at last reached critical mass; has become the majority.

Chip Ford

FIND AND CALL YOUR STATE SENATOR


The Taunton Gazette
Saturday, June 1, 2002

A Gazette editorial
In a twist, residents calling for more taxes

For whatever the reason, there is little alarm among Massachusetts' taxpayers over the spiraling tax revenue deficit.

If there is a month in which tax receipts can be expected to go up, or at least level off, it is April, the month of income tax returns. But turning into May, and as the House sent its budget to the Senate, the Department of Revenue was announcing that tax receipts in early May were $170 million less than expected.

The shortfall was attributed to the fall-off in capital gains taxes, indicating again how much of the state's tax revenue was tied to capital gains. It was the locomotive that pulled the economic train, and the mistake was budget makers failing to realize that the engine could run out of steam.

Blame governors and legislators for not recognizing that,  but remember that just behind us was an era in which Wall Street was considered the safe way of putting your money to work for you. This confidence went so far as to lead to serious discussion of investing Social Security funds in the stock market, or at least allowing workers the right to invest part of their Social Security tax.

The market's tumble has put an end to most of that kind of talk. It also is continuing to wreak havoc on the state budget. The latest decline in tax receipts undoubtedly will necessitate the state dipping into the so-called "rainy day" fund again just to get through to the next fiscal year, beginning July 1.

And the oddity among those on Beacon Hill is the amount of mail lawmakers are continuing to receive, not in opposition to tax increases, but asking for more of them. This is unparalleled in perhaps the history of any state, taxpayers standing up and declaring they prefer to retain programs and protect jobs and to heck with what it might cost them in taxes.

A conclusion gaining support is that the number on the public payroll has swelled so much over the years that nearly every family in the commonwealth has a member or a relative, or knows someone down the street, who is employed in the public sector and who would suffer from program cuts or the elimination of jobs.

Those who aren't affected in some way by such cutbacks are fast becoming the minority taxpayers, and this offers a whole new game for lawmakers.

Return to top


NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml


Return to CLT Updates page

Return to CLT home page