CITIZENS   FOR  LIMITED  TAXATION
and the
Citizens Economic Research Foundation

CLT UPDATE
Friday, February 17, 2006

A rally in search of a reason


The first six weeks of this session have been dominated by private talks over dueling, high stakes House and Senate plans to drastically overhaul health care laws in an effort to get insurance into the hands of hundreds of thousands of individuals who lack it.

Health care talks have monopolized the attention of legislative leaders, and left advocates of myriad budget accounts and policy changes cooling their heels.

State House News Service
Advances -- Week of February 12, 2006
[Excerpt] -- Health care talks


Two Massachusetts teachers' unions yesterday endorsed a citizen's initiative for a constitutional amendment guaranteeing access to affordable healthcare for all state residents.

The Boston Globe
Friday, February 17, 2006
Teachers' unions endorse healthcare bill


The Massachusetts Teachers Association (MTA) board of directors approved a motion to hold a statewide rally in Boston this year, despite internal information that such a rally lacks majority support among the union's local affiliates.

The Education Intelligence Agency
Communiqué – February 13, 2006
Mass. Teachers Association to Hold Rally Despite Lukewarm Support


Chip Ford's CLT Commentary

While The Best Legislature Money Can Buy is still wandering about aimlessly, "handing out citations and kissing babies" as Senate Minority Leader Brian Lees (R-East Longmeadow) describes it, the issue of health care reform -- and who will pay for it -- continues to loom large on the horizon.

On Tuesday, Barbara attended a forum of experts in Salem and has addressed it in her column this week, which will appear here early next week.

The latest entry into the discussion is none other than the teachers unions -- though how this issue affects education eludes me.  The link this time can't be that it's "for the children," already covered by MassHealth.  Of course if it costs taxpayers more money, it'll have the teachers unions' support.

But the teachers union has its own internal problems it should reflect upon:  apparently there's little rank-and-file interest in a rally the union bosses hope to organize.  What if you threw a rally and nobody showed up?  "The union has yet to decide why it will rally," the Education Intelligence Agency reported.  Maybe if the union can come up with an excuse for one, something relevant to complain about, it might generate some interest among its members?  Teachers get perennial pay raises, step increases, generous sick-days and vacation time-off, pensions and health insurance, all at taxpayers expense.  No wonder there's so little enthusiasm.  What do they have left to "rally" about -- or for?  It appears that the teachers union these days is simply struggling to justify its existence.

Chip Ford


State House News Service
Advances -- Week of February 12, 2006
[Excerpt]

Health care talks


The first six weeks of this session have been dominated by private talks over dueling, high stakes House and Senate plans to drastically overhaul health care laws in an effort to get insurance into the hands of hundreds of thousands of individuals who lack it.

Health care talks have monopolized the attention of legislative leaders, and left advocates of myriad budget accounts and policy changes cooling their heels.

"It’s holding up everything else because of the money," said one activist who has closely tracked state government for many years.

The main parties to the talks are the six conference committee members and Senate President Robert Travaglini and House Speaker Salvatore DiMasi. Everyone else on the Hill, including the other more than 190 members of the Legislature, are waiting for a breakthrough.

During one of the few formal Senate sessions of the year last week, Senate Minority Leader Brian Lees (R-East Longmeadow) referenced an old saying that politics is all about handing out citations and kissing babies.

"Basically that’s what our job has been has been so far this year," Lees said. "We have not been in session much because the chair knows right now that health care is holding all kinds of things up and we’re working diligently to change that and hopefully that will happen and then a slew of things will come through here."

Several factors appear to be working against major expansion in health care, including reports that the federal government is seriously looking to control growth in Medicaid and other entitlement programs in an effort to restrain the growing federal budget deficit. Business groups are persistently opposing a proposed payroll tax aimed at generating revenues to cover the uninsured. And House and Senate leaders charged with striking a deal appear to have dug their heels in, despite public statements about steady progress and consensus on many of the relevant issues.

Factors working towards the development of a consensus bill include the threatened loss of huge amounts of federal funding, the general feeling that the existing situation is untenable for both the uninsured and the insured, the bill’s role in the development on next year’s state budget, and the fact that Beacon Hill leaders have put their political capital on the line and promised an agreement. Lastly, initiative petitions and constitutional amendments calling for sweeping health care reforms are advancing on their own separate tracks.

Return to top


The Boston Globe
Friday, February 17, 2006

News Briefs
Teachers' unions endorse healthcare bill


Two Massachusetts teachers' unions yesterday endorsed a citizen's initiative for a constitutional amendment guaranteeing access to affordable healthcare for all state residents.

The Massachusetts Teachers Association represents 95,000 educators, administrators, and other professionals; the Massachusetts Federation of Teachers represents more than 22,000 teachers, nurses, bus drivers, and librarians.

The amendment, which would require the state to provide access to necessary health and mental health services including prescription drugs, must receive an approval vote by 50 legislators at the 2006 Constitutional Convention in May before it would appear on the November ballot.

Return to top


The Education Intelligence Agency
Communiqué – February 13, 2006
On the Web at http://www.eiaonline.com

[Excerpt]
Massachusetts Teachers Association to Hold Rally
Despite Lukewarm Support


The Massachusetts Teachers Association (MTA) board of directors approved a motion to hold a statewide rally in Boston this year, despite internal information that such a rally lacks majority support among the union's local affiliates.

Prior to the vote, the MTA board surveyed more than 100 local affiliates to gauge support for a statewide rally. Forty-six failed to respond, five were uncertain about the idea, 32 said no, and 32 said yes (of the latter, 15 claimed they would have trouble getting members to attend).

Perhaps the response reflected MTA's own ambiguity. The union has yet to decide why it will rally. The MTA board authorized the demonstration and the establishment of a committee to determine what the demonstration will be about. MTA has a budget line-item specifically for public protests.

I'm picturing the committee sitting quietly in a union hall somewhere, having doughnuts and coffee, when some bright light exclaims, "How about a rally for more funding?" upon which they all shout, "Brilliant!" and a poker game breaks out.

Return to top


NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml


Return to CLT Updates page

Return to CLT home page