Limited Taxation
Post Office Box 408     Peabody, Massachusetts   01960     (508) 384-0100

Barbara's Column
May 2000 #2

Governs Least, Governs Better

The Sun
Lowell, Mass.
Sunday, May 14, 2000

Govern Less, Govern Better
By Barbara Anderson

"That government which governs least, governs best".

This Thomas Jefferson quote has hung on my office wall for two decades. So if the Massachusetts Legislature rarely meets, this is fine with me.

The only reason I might like to see it meet more often is to undo some of the damage it has done while meeting in the past. Come to work, guys, and repeal that income tax rate hike. Repeal the gun control law. Repeal the payraises you gave yourselves in 1994.

It would be nice if major items were not done in informal session, without roll calls, or in the middle of the night.

Every now and then there's a real debate like those on abortion, parental choice in education, or the death penalty, with most members understanding the issue and voting their real convictions instead of merely following the leader. At such times one can almost imagine what "governs best" might look like, whether one agrees with the final decision or not. But look quick; it's not an ongoing image.

The problem isn't a shortage of time spent in session. In some states, the legislature meets for only a few months and/or biennially. A citizen legislature like New Hampshire's is more representative of the people than the professional legislators who define themselves as "them" vs. "us."

Over the years, citizen groups have tried to come up with a magic formula that will fix Beacon Hill. The first in my memory was the League of Women Voters' successful campaign to cut the size of the Massachusetts House; the theory was that a smaller body would be more manageable. This turned out to be true, but with almost a majority of legislators getting, or in line to get, leadership pay if they do what the Speaker wants, the Speaker gets to do the managing. The League "reform" made things much worse.

The next was the Rules Reform initiative petition drive led by Citizens for Limited Taxation (CLT), Citizens for Participation in Political Action (CPPAX), Common Cause, the Massachusetts Republican Party and dissident Democrat activists. The idea was to open up the legislative process and give citizens all across the political spectrum a level playing field. Instead, we citizens were told by the Supreme Judicial Court to get off the field altogether.

The Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation tried to get a constitutional amendment for a six month legislative session. CLT later tried a statutory approach for a shorter session: legislators would be paid only for six months, then expected to live and work in the real world for the rest of the year. Neither petition made it to the ballot.

Remember the popular Term Limits petitions of the early '90s? The legislature and the SJC killed them too.

Common Cause recently won its version of a reform issue with its voter-approved Clean Elections Law, to limit campaign contributions and allow public financing of elections. The House just put it in a deadly "study committee."

Republicans have argued for years that the best reform would be a viable two-party legislature and I'm sure they've been right, albeit generally not elected. Voters complain about the process, but usually vote for the usual processors even when there's a choice.

Despite the fact that I've supported many of the above concepts, I've finally faced this reality: there are no magic formulas, and if there were one, the SJC or the Legislature would kill it at the first opportunity.

If Jefferson was right, that the government which governs least, governs best, then our best hope is that legislators won't show up too often.

For almost $50,000 a year base pay, that's the least they can do.

Barbara Anderson is executive director of Citizens for Limited Taxation. Her syndicated columns appear weekly in the Salem Evening News and the Lowell Sun; bi-weekly in the Tinytown Gazette; and occasionally in other newspapers.

Return to Barbara's Columns page